Friday Aug 24, 2007
 

Off the Shelf Politics...

I still spend a few days every month at the bookstore where I worked before joining ABA, and I'll be there tonight.  I'm planning to take advantage of the relative calm of a Friday evening to do my usual reshelving.  Maybe it's just me, but I find some kind of satisfaction in taking The Autobiography of Miss Jane Pittman out of the biography section, or moving Lush from middle reader to YA (just because it's a skinny book doesn't mean it's targeted at third graders!) or adding to my ever-interesting list of non-fiction books shelved as novels.  (MayflowerWaiting for Snow in Havana?  What's the least fiction-like book you've found in your fiction section?)

At least I haven't had to deal with these people.

Under the heading "Biologists Helping Bookstores," the bloggers and many of the commenters make it their mission to support their side of the evolution-intelligent design debate by "correcting" the situation when they find ID-related books shelved as science. 

Although a number of booksellers have posted comments in protest (particularly chain-store employees explaining that moving a book to another section doesn't change its official corporate classification), many of the commenters, along with the blog founder, have a surprising lack of respect for booksellers - or maybe "patronization" is the word.  Consider this comment:

If employees have to make a little extra effort to find a book, that's a small price to pay for intellectual honesty. Keep up the good work!

Or:

Almost hiding on the bottom shelf are two ID books by Jonathan Wells (of the hilarious Discovery Institute), perilously close to Watson's The Double Helix - for frak's sake, have they no shame? These seem to be particularly nasty and specious examples of the nonscience I aim to reclassify.

And:

You are awesome. I want to be a science vigilante too.

Some booksellers have attempted to point out that this is not the way to do things:

As a longtime bookstore employee, I can confirm that, when deciding where to shelve books, the thought foremost in booksellers' minds is, "Will this book sell from this spot?" At my bookstore, we attempt to shelve books where we think customers who don't want to ask for help in finding things will spot them.

Moving books to another section of the store is not "helping" or "making a statement"; it is making a mess. It makes finding a book much harder for the employee who has looked it up in the computer because it's not where it's supposed to be. It means the possibility of a lost sale because the book cannot be found, at least for the moment. It means more work for already underpaid sales clerks to have to move the books back to where they originally were -- because, rest assured, that's what will probably happen.

A friendly email to the manager or buyers at your local bookstore, suggesting changes and your reasons why, would probably have a greater lasting effect.

Thanks to the most recent entry, we know that at least one ABA member has been visited by the blog founder (and met with his/her approval).  Does anyone else have stories of "bookstore vigilantism?" 


Comments:

Most of my 'helpful' reshelvers have done so for two other reasons: they wanted to 'save' the book from being bought by others so that they could come back and purchase it for themselves (this done mostly by youngsters without parents in tow) or the subject matter was disturbing and/or offensive for that particular customer so the title was buried behind other books on some tall shelf. Any way you look at helpful reshelvers it all boils down to the fact that people are looking and reading and in most cases buying!! And I can live with that!

Posted by 216.228.51.212 on August 24, 2007 at 03:50 PM EDT #

Just today I found a copy of Joan Anderson's "Weekend to Change Your Life" quite "helpfully" placed upon the fiction shelf, in the proper alphabetical place no less. I don't think anyone had any malicious and/or subversive objective; they just thought it belonged there.

I've never encountered any individuals that have purposefully reshelved books to sections they see fit, but we recently recieved a call from an irate woman who couldn't believe that we would have a book like "Walter the Farting Dog" in our window for the public to see. Farting was just too obscene a word to be in our window apparently.

Posted by Ben on August 26, 2007 at 04:08 PM EDT #

In 1980, when I began my first job in publishing, Random House still had a periodical orientation for new hires that was given my the house's co-founder Donald Klopfer, who was a most remarkable man. One thing I still recall is his anecdote about Bennett Cerf (the more famous RH co-founder) calling on bookstore accounts and assiduously facing out the RH titles!

Posted by Dan on August 30, 2007 at 11:27 AM EDT #

Post a Comment:
  • HTML Syntax: Allowed

Search Blog

Feeds

Links

Navigation

Referers