- Categories:
Gift Cards vs. Paper Gift Certificates: Analysis of Potential Returns [4]
Over the last few weeks as ABA staff has spoken with booksellers about the new Book Sense electronic gift card program, a number of booksellers have asked the question: "In purely financial terms, how many more gift cards will I have to sell to achieve the same number of gross profit dollars as I would have selling paper gift certificates?"
To provide an answer to this question, ABA has prepared a three-year analysis of potential returns comparing paper gift certificate and electronic gift card sales.
The assumptions are:
- Figures are based upon gross year-one sales of $3,000 for gift certificates.
- There is a cost of $0.41 each for paper certificates.
- The costs for the electronic gift cards are those included in the financial analysis found at http://www.bookweb.org/read/6336. [5]
- All cards and certificates are used.
- Set-up fees are included, but equipment costs are not.
Note: If the starting figure of $3,000 is not appropriate for your operation, we invite you to download this spreadsheet [6] (Excel format), which will automatically calculate the comparison results based upon any gross sales amount that you supply.
Year 1:
|
Paper
|
Plastic
|
Plastic +5%
|
Plastic +10%
|
Plastic +15%
|
Plastic +20%
|
Plastic +25%
|
Plastic +30%
|
Plastic +35%
|
Plastic +40%
|
Plastic +45%
|
Plastic +50%
|
Plastic +55%
|
$ sales |
3,000
|
3,000
|
3,150
|
3,300
|
3,450
|
3,600
|
3,750
|
3,900
|
4,050
|
4,200
|
4,350
|
4,500
|
4,650
|
Program cost |
-49
|
-387
|
-394
|
-400
|
-406
|
-412
|
-418
|
-424
|
-430
|
-436
|
-442
|
-449
|
-455
|
COG |
-1,830
|
-1,830
|
-1,922
|
-2,013
|
-2,105
|
-2,196
|
-2,288
|
-2,379
|
-2,471
|
-2,562
|
-2,654
|
-2,745
|
-2,837
|
GP $ |
1,121
|
783
|
835
|
887
|
940
|
992
|
1,045
|
1,097
|
1,149
|
1,202
|
1,254
|
1,306
|
1,359
|
Year 2 (10% increase):
|
Paper
|
Plastic
|
Plastic +5%
|
Plastic +10%
|
Plastic +15%
|
Plastic +20%
|
Plastic +25%
|
Plastic +30%
|
Plastic +35%
|
Plastic +40%
|
Plastic +45%
|
Plastic +50%
|
Plastic +55%
|
$ sales |
3,300
|
3,300
|
3,465
|
3,630
|
3,795
|
3,960
|
4,125
|
4,290
|
4,455
|
4,620
|
4,785
|
4,950
|
5,115
|
Program cost |
-54
|
-375
|
-381
|
-388
|
-395
|
-402
|
-408
|
-415
|
-447
|
-453
|
-460
|
-467
|
-474
|
COG |
-2,013
|
-2,013
|
-2,114
|
-2,214
|
-2,315
|
-2,416
|
-2,516
|
-2,617
|
-2,718
|
-2,818
|
-2,919
|
-3,020
|
-3,120
|
GP $ |
1,233
|
912
|
970
|
1,028
|
1,085
|
1,143
|
1,200
|
1,258
|
1,291
|
1,348
|
1,406
|
1,464
|
1,521
|
Year 3 (10% increase):
|
Paper
|
Plastic
|
Plastic +5%
|
Plastic +10%
|
Plastic +15%
|
Plastic +20%
|
Plastic +25%
|
Plastic +30%
|
Plastic +35%
|
Plastic +40%
|
Plastic +45%
|
Plastic +50%
|
Plastic +55%
|
$ sales |
3,630
|
3,630
|
3,812
|
3,993
|
4,175
|
4,356
|
4,538
|
4,719
|
4,901
|
5,082
|
5,264
|
5,445
|
5,627
|
Program cost |
-60
|
-388
|
-396
|
-403
|
-410
|
-418
|
-425
|
-433
|
-465
|
-472
|
-480
|
-487
|
-495
|
COG |
-2,214
|
-2,214
|
-2,325
|
-2,436
|
-2,546
|
-2,657
|
-2,768
|
-2,879
|
-2,989
|
-3,100
|
-3,211
|
-3,321
|
-3,432
|
GP $ |
1,356
|
1,028
|
1,091
|
1,154
|
1,218
|
1,281
|
1,344
|
1,408
|
1,446
|
1,510
|
1,573
|
1,636
|
1,700
|